'His only crime was being a young
black guy buying a $300 belt': Queens student arrested after buying Ferragamo
belt sues Barneys
·
Trayon
Christian, 19, taken to NYPD precinct despite using his own debit card and ID
at the upscale Manhattan store
·
The
college student, who lives with his mom in Queens, New York, had saved up from
his part-time job to buy the Salvatore Ferragamo belt
·
Mr
Christian is suing Barneys and NYPD for unspecified damages
A
black college student who had saved up money from his part-time job to buy a
designer belt at Barneys department store was pounced on by police 'because he
could not afford to make such an expensive purchase', according to a new
lawsuit.
Trayon
Christian, 19, filed a lawsuit on Tuesday for unspecified damages against the
Madison Avenue store and the NYPD who wrongly accused him of fraud.
Mr
Christian, who lives with his mom in Queens, had decided to splash out on a
$320 belt by designer Salvatore Ferragamo after seeing one of his favorite
music stars, Harlem rapper Juelz Santana, wearing the accessory.
Trayon
Christian, 19, has brought a lawsuit against Barneys and the NYPD after they
wrongly accused him of fraud when he purchased a designer belt
Barneys
department store is facing a lawsuit after a 19-year-old black student claims
he was wrongly grabbed by store detectives because of his color and accused of
stealing a designer belt
However
once he had paid for the belt and had left Barneys on April 29 this year, the
fashion-loving teen was grabbed by undercover officers on the street.
According
to the civil rights lawsuit, the 19-year-old was asked 'how a young black man
such as himself could afford to purchase such an expensive belt'.
'His
only crime was being a young black guy buying a $300 belt.'
A
Barneys store employee had asked the 19-year-old for ID when he used his Chase
debit card to buy the belt. Mr Christian showed the clerk his state ID.
The
store cashier then subsequently called the police to claim that the purchase
was a fraud, according to the lawsuit.
Officers
took the teenager, who is an engineering freshman at the NYC College of
Technology, to a local precinct.
Mr
Christian once again showed his ID, debit card and receipt for the belt.
Officers
still refused to believe the teenager.
'In
spite of producing such documentation Christian was told that his
identification was false and that he could not afford to make such an expensive
purchase,' the suit states.
Finally
Chase bank was contacted who verified that the debit card belonged to Mr
Christian.
It
was only then that he was allowed to go after spending two hours in a holding
cell, the suit claims.
The
NYPD denied this and said the student was only held for 42 minutes.
The
student, who has no history of arrests, said that he will never shop at Barneys
again following the incident.
The
teenager, who now works at Target, told the News: 'I brought the belt back to
Barneys a few days later and returned it. I got my money back, I’m not shopping
there again. It’s cruel. It’s racist.'
A
Barney's New York spokesman said: 'Barneys New York typically does not comment
on pending litigation.
'In
this instance, we feel compelled to note that after carefully reviewing the
incident of last April, it is clear that no employee of Barneys New York was
involved in the pursuit of any action with the individual other than the
sale.
'Barneys
New York has zero tolerance for any form of discrimination and we stand by our
long history in support of all human rights.'
(ALSO)
Male supermodel Tyson Beckford says he gets racially profiled 'all the time' in Barney's as row rumbles on over two customers who say they were stopped because they were black
One of the
world's most successful male models has waded into the row over whether
Barney's flagship superstore in Manhattan racially profiles its customers.
Fashion
megastar Tyson Beckford, 42, told PIX11 on Thursday that he
frequently gets judged on the color of his skin in Barney's and other places.
And
on Friday it was revealed that another high-end shop, Macy's, is facing a
lawsuit from customer who says he was mistreated and humiliated due to the
color of his skin.
'I
might have the most recognizable face in the world. I still get followed all
the time, any time I go to a store,' Beckford said outside Barney's on
Thursday.
Target:
World famous male model Tyson Beckford said that even he is racially profiled
when he goes into stores like Barney's and elsewhere
Barney's
has also issued an apology and stated that they are employing a civil rights
expert to look at how they treat customers at the luxury store.
Meanwhile
Jay-Z is coming under pressure to drop his clothing deal with the high-end
store.
Tyson
Beckford was interviewed by PIX11 as he came out of Barney's flagship store on
fashionable Madison Avenue near 60th Street in Manhattan.
'I just went in there now to go to a casting and security is looking at me. It's sad,' said the model who first hit fame when he became the face of Ralph Lauren's Polo range in 1993.
Also
on Thursday, Barney's CEO Mark Lee posted a statement on their Facebook page
that began: 'Barneys New York believes that no customer should have the
unacceptable experience described in recent media reports, and we offer our
sincere regret and deepest apologies.'
The
note added that the store has 'zero tolerance for any form of discrimination.
We are a strong proponent of equal rights and equal treatment for all human
beings.
Trouble:
Barney's flagship store in Manhattan is in a row about whether it racially
profiles its black customers after two young New Yorkers complained about their
treatment this week
'Our
mission is to ensure that all customers receive the highest-quality service -
without exception.'
Lee
then announced that the company is hiring civil rights expert, Michael Yaki,
who also works on the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, to work with the store
on this issue.
Then
on Friday, Robert Brown, of Brooklyn, became the third young person in a week
to take legal action complaining of racial profiling by high-end Manhattan
stores.
The New
York Daily News reported that Brown is filing a lawsuit against Macy's
after he was allegedly 'paraded' through the store in handcuffs after employees
accused him of making a fraudulent purchase.
Brown
claims he was then unlawfully stopped and held by police, who told him that his
ID was 'false and that he could not afford to make such an expensive purchase.'
'No
facts existed that would give rise to the inference that either the
identification or debit/credit card was fake, false, fraudulent, altered,
tampered, or in any other way unlawful,' the suit states, as reported by the
Daily News.
The
suit says that Brown was humiliated by the experience before he was released
without charges.
It
accuses Macy's and the police of acting against Brown 'based on (his) race and
age as he was a young black American male.'
But
Beckford is just the latest big name to become embroiled in the row over
Barney's treatment of black customers, as Jay-Z has come in criticism over his
Christmas deal with the store.
The
controversy began when two young black New Yorkers came forward to say that
they had been stopped and detained after buying expensive items from the luxury
shop.
'Sad':
'I just went in there now to go to a casting and security is looking at me.
It's sad,' said the model who first hit fame when he became the face of Ralph
Lauren's Polo range in 1993
BARNEY'S APOLOGY IN FULL
Barneys
New York believes that no customer should have the unacceptable experience
described in recent media reports, and we offer our sincere regret and deepest
apologies.
Further to our statement of yesterday, we want to reinforce that Barneys New York has zero tolerance for any form of discrimination. We are a strong proponent of equal rights and equal treatment for all human beings. Our mission is to ensure that all customers receive the highest-quality service—without exception.
To this end, we are conducting a thorough review of our practices and procedures as they relate to these matters to ensure that they reflect our continued commitment to fairness and equality. To lead this review, we have retained a civil rights expert, Michael Yaki, who also serves on the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. The Commission has been the nation's watchdog for civil rights for more than 50 years. Mr. Yaki will be provided with unrestricted access to all aspects of our store operations.
In addition, Barneys New York has reached out to community leaders to begin a dialogue on this important issue.
Sincerely,
Mark Lee
CEO of Barneys New York
Further to our statement of yesterday, we want to reinforce that Barneys New York has zero tolerance for any form of discrimination. We are a strong proponent of equal rights and equal treatment for all human beings. Our mission is to ensure that all customers receive the highest-quality service—without exception.
To this end, we are conducting a thorough review of our practices and procedures as they relate to these matters to ensure that they reflect our continued commitment to fairness and equality. To lead this review, we have retained a civil rights expert, Michael Yaki, who also serves on the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. The Commission has been the nation's watchdog for civil rights for more than 50 years. Mr. Yaki will be provided with unrestricted access to all aspects of our store operations.
In addition, Barneys New York has reached out to community leaders to begin a dialogue on this important issue.
Sincerely,
Mark Lee
CEO of Barneys New York
Under
pressure: Jay-Z is coming under pressure from social media and even his own
home neighborhood to drop his lucrative Holiday tie-in with Barneys after two
alleged incidents of racial profiling at their flagship store
Trayon
Christian, 19, from Queens and Kayla Phillips, 21, a seven-month pregnant
mother from Canarsie, Brooklyn
Jay-Z
is coming under pressure from social media and even residents of the Brooklyn
neighborhood where he grew up to cancel his multi-million dollar Christmas
tie-in with Barneys.
The
superstar rapper, has signed a contract to design an exclusive line for the
Manhattan superstore available next month and the 43-year-old will also be called
upon to decorate one of the store's iconic Christmas windows.
However,
in light of the news that two black shoppers have accused Barney's and the NYPD
of racially profiling them after they purchased expensive items at the Madison
Avenue store, a petition has been signed calling on Jay-Z to reconsider his
contract.
Indeed,
the residents of Marcy House, in Brooklyn, where Jay-Z grew up as Shawn Carter
have called on the '99 Problems' rapper and husband of Beyonce to think about
those who have not become as succesful as him.
'Jay
Z and my son grew up together,' said Effie Hardy, 74, to the New
York Daily News.
Expensive:
Items available from Jay-Z's new exclusive line at Barneys called 'A New York
Holiday' - which has products available for tens of thousands of dollars
'That
could be his family Barneys is profiling. They would’ve done the same thing to
him back in the day, before he got to where he is now. He should remember
that.'
The
luxury and exclusive collection that Jay-Z has lent his considerable clout to
is named 'A New York Holiday,' and the cheapest item is a $70 cotton T-shirt
while a Shawn Carter watch by Hublot with alligator skin straps will cost an
incredible $33,900.
Another
Marcy resident, Annette Rush, 40, told the New
York Daily News that as a role model, Jay-Z should think about the ramifications
of the two shoppers allegations.
'My
money is as good as anybody else’s money. It’s all green,' said Rush.
'From
someone that came from the hood, he should know all that. He knows how hard it
is.
'I
don’t think he should sell his things there, not at a place where there’s
racial profiling going on. It’s ridiculous.'
On
Tuesday, Trayon Christian said that he was suing the city and Barneys after he
was accosted by two undercover NYPD detectives after he had bought a $349
Ferragamo belt.
Evocative:
This Twitter user tries to invoke Jay-Z's paternal instincts by questioning how
he would feel if his daughter was racially profiled as it is alleged the NYPD
and Barneys profiled two black customers
And
then on Wednesday, Kayla Phillips said that she too had been stopped. The young
mother, from Brooklyn, New York, said she experienced similarly shocking
treatment from staff at the Madison Avenue store in February when she bought a
$2,500 Céline handbag.
She
has now filed a $5 million notice of claim with the city showing her intention
to sue the NYPD.
'As
I was walking into the train station, four undercover police officers attacked
me,' Phillips told the New York Post.
'They
were very rough,' she added to the New York Daily News. 'I didn't know what was
happening.'
She
explained to the cops that she had used a temporary Bank of America card to
make the purchase - and they demanded to know why her name was not on it.
Complaint:
Kayla Phillips, 21, says cops demanded to know how she could afford to buy a
$2,500 Céline bag from Barneys in New York - in a case that echoes that of a
teen accusing the store of racial profiling
Shock:
She called her mother Wendy Straker (right with Kayla) who said she heard
police ask her daughter: 'What are you doing here in Manhattan? Where'd you get
the money to buy that expensive bag?'
She
called her mother, Wendy Straker, who said that the police officers had asked
her daughter: 'What are you doing here in Manhattan? Where'd you get the money
to buy that expensive bag?'
Straker
added that the police were on the phone with a Barneys employee about the
transaction.
Police
finally let her go after she showed them her ID and new debit card, which
arrived that morning.
'Jay
Z is getting ready to do a campaign with Barneys, but they’re looking at these
African-American kids like they're thieves,' Straker said.
The
case comes after it emerged that another shopper, Trayon Christian, was stopped
and handcuffed after he bought a $350 Salvatore Ferragamo belt in the store.
Treat:
She had just bought a $2,500 orange suede Céline handbag when she was stopped
by cops
Christian,
19, has now filed a lawsuit for unspecified damages against the Madison Avenue
store and the NYPD who wrongly accused him of fraud.
Mr
Christian, who lives with his mom in Queens, had decided to splash out on the
belt after seeing one of his favorite music stars, Harlem rapper Juelz Santana,
wearing the accessory.
However
once he had paid for the belt and had left Barneys on April 29 this year, the
fashion-loving teen was grabbed by undercover officers on the street.
According
to the civil rights lawsuit, the 19-year-old was asked 'how a young black man
such as himself could afford to purchase such an expensive belt'.
Mr
Christian's lawyer Michael Palillo told the New York Daily News: 'He's never
been arrested. His only crime was being a young black guy buying a $300 belt.'
(PLUS)
Al Sharpton condemns 'shop and frisk' at Manhattan stores and threatens direct action against Barneys after racial profiling claims
·Reverend Al Sharpton has accused Barney's of 'upscale racial
profiling' after they allegedly called police on two black customers who bought
expensive items
·He said blacks and Latinos worry about being
'stopped-and-frisked' by police and 'shopped-and-frisked' in retail stores
·Sharpton has demanded a meeting with Barneys and
called for a boycott of the retailer
Civil rights activist Reverend Al Sharpton has threatened protests
against New York retailer Barneys and a possible boycott for 'upscale racial
profiling' after two black shoppers said they were discriminated against.
'In
major cities like New York, blacks and Latinos not only worry about being
“stopped-and-frisked” by police, but they also fear the embarrassment of being
“shopped-and-frisked” in retail stores,' he said in an opinion piece for
the New
York Daily News.
'Perhaps
all retailers need a friendly reminder of the immense buying power of blacks
and minorities. We will definitely remember those who welcome us and those who
would rather profile us, and we will speak loudly with our dollars — bottom
line.'
Time
for action:The Rev. Al Sharpton has condemned 'shop and frisk' at Manhattan
stores and called for a boycott of Barneys
Two
black Barneys customers said this week they were detained by police after
making expensive purchases.
Trayon
Christian, 19, sued Barneys, saying he was accosted by undercover NYPD officers
after using his debit card to buy a $349 Ferragamo belt in April.
Kayla
Phillips, 21, said she was surrounded and interrogated by police after
purchasing a $2,500 handbag from Barneys in February.
Sharpton
said it was a 'travesty' that police and retailers interrogate black people who
buy expensive items.
'Barneys, a high-end retailer with stores in major cities, must answer for this pattern of biased behavior, as must the NYPD,' he wrote.
'Our
National Action Network (NAN) Brooklyn chapter President Kirsten John Foy said
it best when he called Barneys’ behavior schizophrenic. On the one hand, they
want to expand their brand to the urban market, but then they turn around and
see us as suspects rather than prospects.
'Barneys
and other retailers that openly discriminate against us must be held
accountable. Simply apologizing isn’t enough; we need to see a plan of action
as to how they are going to rectify their ways.'
Accountability:
Sharpton said Barneys, a high-end retailer with stores in major cities, must
answer for its 'pattern of biased behavior'
Sharpton
has demanded a meeting with Barneys CEO, Mark Lee, and is 'currently mobilizing
activists for peaceful direct-action against the store and the NYPD.'
Earlier
this week, Lee said the company had retained a civil rights expert to help
review its procedures and offered his 'sincere regret and deepest apologies'.
'Barneys
New York has zero tolerance for any form of discrimination and we stand by our
long history in support of all human rights,' Barneys said in a statement.
In
his comment piece, Sharpton also highlighted the experiences of 'Treme' actor,
Rob Brown, and Oscar-winning actor Forest Whitaker.
Brown
claimed he was paraded through Macy’s Herald Square in handcuffs and placed in
a holding cell because an employee suspected that his credit card didn’t belong
to him in June,
Whitaker
said he was accused of stealing and patted down after leaving a store in
Morningside Heights.
'When
international celebrities can be disrespected and mistreated in such a
humiliating manner, how can we ever naively believe that our work is done?'
Sharpton wrote.
Shocking:
Trayon Christian, 19, left, and Kayla Phillips, 21, claim they were
interrogated by police after buying expensive items from Barneys
For what nation is
there so great, who hath God so
nigh unto them, as the Lord our God is in all things that we call
upon him for?
Deuteronomy 4:8
Deuteronomy 4:8
And what nation is
there so great, that hath
statutes and judgments so righteous as all this law, which I set before you
this day?
Deuteronomy 28:37
Deuteronomy 28:37
And thou shalt become an
astonishment, a proverb, and a byword,
among all nations whither the Lord shall lead thee.
Lamentations 2:16
Lamentations 2:16
All thine enemies have opened
their mouth against thee: they hiss and
gnash the teeth: they say, We have swallowed her up: certainly this is the day
that we looked for; we have found, we have seen it.
Ezekiel 13:4
Ezekiel 13:4
O Israel, thy prophets are
like the foxes in the deserts.
No comments:
Post a Comment